Court of Appeal
Date17th January 2020
TypeCriminal
Criminal Appeals

List to Fix Dates and Management List
See Updated Notice in the Notices section as to the current arrangements for these Lists and for information as to the time for replying submissions and agreed Book of Authorities.

Sentence appeals and undue leniency applications
See Practice Direction (CA02) for requirements as to materials (reports, testimonials etc) for the use of the court in sentence appeals and undue leniency applications.

Chief Prosecution Solicitor - service of documents and notification of any intended application
Practitioners are reminded of the requirement to serve on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor for the Director of Public Prosecutions written submissions lodged in the court office. Except for the documents referred to in Order 86C Rule 7 (1) (a notice of appeal or a notice of application pursuant to section 2 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1993) and in Order 86C Rule 15(1) (a notice of abandonment) notice of which the Registrar is required to give to various parties including the Chief Prosecution Solicitor all other documents lodged in the court office must be served on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor. Notice of any intended application to the Court must be given to the Chief Prosecution Solicitor as well as to the court office.

Civil Appeals for case-management and hearing in the Criminal Courts of Justice
The attention of practitioners in civil appeals for case-management and hearing in the Criminal Courts of Justice is drawn to the provisions of Order 86 Rule 12 (5) (motions) and Order 86A Rule 16 (1)
(directions hearings) as to the requirement for the lodgement in the court office of the relevant booklets.

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
246/19 DPP -v- KL (Powderly Solicitors)
240/18 DPP -v- Sean Hannaway (Thompson Solicitors)
276/16 DPP -v- James Davy (Thompson Solicitors)
140/19 DPP -v- Declan McDarmott (Thompson Solicitors)
225/19 DPP -v- Mark Adkins (Fiona D'Arcy Solicitors)
229/19 DPP -v- Andrew Crilly (Connolly Maguire Solicitors)
255/17 DPP -v- Henry Alinta (Kevin Tunney Solicitors)
133/18 DPP -v- DC (Sheehan & Partners)
Motions
172/19 DPP -v- Kevin Walsh (Michael Hennessy Solicitors)
For Review
106/14 DPP -v- Andrzej Benko (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)
Civil Appeals
2017 535 and 536 Ford & Moynihan -v- DPP & ors
2019 510 The Attorney General -v- Matache
2019 538 DPP -v- H
2020 002 DPP -v- O'Reilly
2018 449 Simpson v Governor of Midlands Prison (application to re-enter Art 40 appeal)
2019 412 Simpson v Same (ex parte prisoner appeal for directions)
2019 413 Simpson v Same (ex parte prisoner appeal for directions)
Criminal Appeals
324/16 DPP -v- Colm Simpson (Cyril & Co. Solicitors)
263/18 DPP -v- Lounes Ouachek (Cyril & Co. Solicitors)


AN CHÚIRT
ACHOMHAIRC
THE COURT OF APPEAL

For Monday 20th January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Applications
55CJA/19 DPP -v- Shane Tobin (Frank Buttimer & Co Solicitors)
65CJA/19 DPP -v- Jason Moore (E.A Ryan & Co. Solicitors)

Sentence Appeal
19/18 DPP -v- Rafael Dudek (E.C Gearty & Co. Solicitors)

For Tuesday 21st January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10.00 o'clock
For reference to Court of Justice
Sentence Appeal
214/15 DPP -v- Klass Meijvogel (Conway Solicitors)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10.10 o'clock
For Judgment
Civil Appeal
2019 210 X -v- DPP

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10.20 o'clock
For Judgment
Civil Appeal
2019 256 AB -v- DPP

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction and Sentence Appeal
168/15 DPP -v- Patrick Roche (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)


For Thursday 23rd January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeals
2019 457 The Minister for Justice & Equality -v- Armandas Kacevicius

For Friday 24th January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
117/14 DPP -v- Peter Barry (Burns Nowlan Solicitors)
150/19 &163CJA/19 DPP -v- Patrick Nevin (James MacGuill Solicitor)
300/18 DPP -v- Patrick Nevin (James MacGuill Solicitor)
69/19 DPP -v- Desmond O'Hare (MulhollandLAW)
Enlargement of Time Application
215/19 DPP -v- Jason Power (Joseph Cuddigan & So Solicitors)
Civil Appeal
2020 15 The Minister for Justice & Equality -v- Michal Kubálek

Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Judgment for Delivery
2019 92 AT -v- DPP

The President
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Applications
34CJA/19 DPP -v- Ngako Mangala (Partners at Law Solicitors)
159/CJA/19 DPP -v- Dan Flynn (J.J. Fitzgerald & Co.)
185CJA/19 DPP -v- Garret Hevey (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Monday 27th January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McGovern
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
167CJA/19 DPP -v- Clive Kavanagh (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

Sentence Appeal
206/18 DPP -v- Ion Catan (O'Sullivan Kenny Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
89/19 DPP -v- Richard Donnelly (Gilmartin Solicitors)

For Tuesday 28th January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Application
102/19 DPP -v- Alan Craughwell (Gearoid Geraghty & Co.)

Sentence Appeal
137/19 DPP -v- Nora Atkinson (Michael Kelleher Solicitors)

Undue Leniency Application and Conviction appeal
187CJA/19 and 209/19 DPP -v- Sidney Sutton (Monahan & Co. Solicitors)

For Thursday 30th January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
40/19 DPP -v- Daniel Delaney (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors

Conviction appeal
160/17 DPP -v- Darren Thompson (Michael J. Staines and Co. Solicitors)

For Friday 31st January 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
51/16 DPP-v- Daniel Wyse (John Shanley Solicitors)

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
Enlargement of Time Applications
83/19 DPP -v- Vasile Horvat (Cahir O'Higgins & Company)
173/19 DPP -v- Seamus Marley (Cyril and Co. Solicitors)
235/19 DPP -v- Frank Ryan (Tim Kenneally & Co Solicitors)
13/19 DPP -v- Ray Dore (Herbert & Co Solicitors)

For Monday 3rd February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice Collins
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
47/19 DPP -v- Robert O'Donoghue (Tim Kenneally & Co Solicitors)

Undue Leniency Applications
126CJA/19 DPP -v- Eoin Vickers (Partners at Law Solicitors)
134CJA/19 DPP -v- Craig McGrath (John P. O'Donohoe Solicitors)

For Tuesday 4th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeals
2019 431 E -v- DPP
2019 270 DPP -v- McGrath

For Thursday 6th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
77/19 DPP -v- Roger Meehan (Tracy Horan & Co. Solicitors)
For Monday 17th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
67/19 DPP -v- Brendan Sheehan (Ted McCarthy Solicitors)
36/18 DPP -v- Zaporozcenko (Leonard Leader Solicitors)

Undue Leniency Applications
145CJA/19 DPP -v- Martina McGrath (Newell Gillen & Cunningham Solicitors)
93CJA/18 DPP -v- Mark Dolan (H.R. Delahunty & Co. Solicitors)
152CJA/19 DPP -v- Dale Brazil (Newell Gillen & Cunningham Solicitors)

For Tuesday 18th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeal
2018 37 Fox -v- MJE, Ire & AG

For Thursday 20th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
50/17 DPP -v- Paul Kearney (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
229/18 DPP -v- Stephen O'Sullivan (Peter Connolly Solicitors)

For Friday 21st February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List
For Mention
225/18 DPP -v- Ciaran Maguire (Michael E Hanahoe Solicitors)
233/18 DPP -v- Kevin Braney (Shalom Binchey & Co Solicitors)

At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
141/19 DPP -v- Mairtin Manning (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

Conviction and Sentence Appeal
139/19 DPP -v- Andrius Lipinskas (Kieran Conway Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
243/18 DPP -v- James Kelly (King & Company Solicitors)

For Monday 24th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Undue Leniency Applications
142CJA/19 DPP -v- Michael Cummins (Dermot Lavery & Company Solicitors)
174CJA/19 DPP -v- Bob (Robert) Maxwell (David Peters Solicitors)
35CJA/19 DPP -v- Alan Wall (linked with next 3 cases) (Newell Gillen & Cunningham Solicitors)
36CJA/19 DPP -v- Barry Walsh (Michael Kelleher Solicitors)
37CJA/19 DPP -v- Conor O'Connor (Newell Gillen & Cunningham Solicitors)
38CJA/19 DPP -v- Michael Tynan (John P O'Donoghue & Co Solicitors)

For Tuesday 25th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
147/15 DPP -v- Marius Gaizutis (Sean T O'Reilly & Co. Solicitors)

Conviction and Sentence Appeals
108/19 DPP -v- Alan Clancy (KOD Lyons Solicitors)
7/18 DPP -v- Trevor McDonagh (Ruane & Co Solicitors)

For Thursday 27th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Conviction Appeal
151/13 DPP -v- Brian Shaughnessy (Siuna Bartels & Co. Solicitors)

For Friday 28th February 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case Management List

At 10.30 o'clock
Section 99 Re-Entry
169CJA/19 DPP -v- Ian Farnan (Keenan Fitzgerald Solicitors)

Sentence Appeal
6/19 DPP -v- Joseph Fraser (Ronan O'Brien & Company Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
154/15 DPP -v- Daniel Hayden (Lorraine J Stephens Solicitor)

For Monday 2nd March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence appeal
221/19 DPP v Sarah Clarke (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
110/19 DPP -v- Tom Reilly (Cahir O'Higgins & Co. Solicitors)


Undue Leniency Application
321CJA/18 DPP -v- David Berney (Lorraine J Stephens Solicitor)


For Tuesday 3rd March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
67/18 DPP -v- Eamon Cumberton (John M Quinn Solicitors)

For Thursday 5th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
31/17 DPP v Andrew Reilly (Kevin Tunney Solicitors)
95/19 DPP -v- Daniel Wildes
149/19 DPP -v- Joseph Carey (Michael E. Hanahoe Solicitors)

For Friday 6th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case-mgt List

At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence appeals
264/15 DPP -v- John Heaphy (Diane Hallahan Solicitors)
162/17 DPP -v- Mark Bourke (John Shanley Solicitors)
166/19 DPP -v- Thomas O'Boyle (Philip Hannon Solicitors)


For Monday 9th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
135/19 DPP -v- Bernard Ring (John Shanley Solicitors)
240/19 DPP -v- Romeo Stanescu
211/18 DPP -v- Brandon McDonnell (John J Quinn & Co. Solicitors)


For Tuesday 10th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Donnelly
At 10 o'clock
Re-Sentence Appeal
81/19 DPP -v- Brandon Power (Partners at Law Solicitors)

At 10.30 o'clock
Civil Appeal
2019 392 Barry -v- Governor of Midlands Prison & anor

For Thursday 12th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
129/19 DPP -v- James Joseph Cassidy


For Friday 13th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
210/18 DPP -v- Martin Sherlock (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitors)
205/18 DPP -v- Patrick Joseph O'Reilly (Madden & Finucane Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
45/18 DPP -v- Christopher Mulready (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitors)


For Monday 23rd March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10 o'clock
List to Fix Dates
For list management purposes please notify the Registrar by way of email
to courtofappealcriminal@courts.ie if it is anticipated that any appeal
in the List will realistically exceed a day
Part Heard
14/17 DPP -v- Donall Billings (Bríd Mimnagh & Associates Solicitors)
245/18 DPP -v- Marek Grabowski (O'Dwyer Solicitors)


Conviction Appeals
214/13 DPP -v- John Dundon (Kieran O'Brien Solicitors)
197/17 DPP -v-Christopher McDonald (Tony Collier Solicitors)
313/18 DPP -v- Ray Fitzgerald (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
316/18 DPP -v- Stephen Tynan (Connolly Finan Solicitors)
293/18 DPP -v- Aidan Conroy (T/A S. Bartels & Company)

Sentence Appeal
4/19 DPP -v- Stefan Schaufler (McGovern Walsh & Co. Solicitors)
28/18 DPP -v- Richard Farrell (Farrell McElwee Solicitors)


Appeals list at 11 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
285/15 DPP -v- Michael Moran (O'Flaherty Brown Solicitors)
7/19 DPP -v- Sarah Doran (Kieran Conway Solicitors)

Conviction and Sentence Appeal
257/17 DPP -v- Seamus Langan (Robinson O'Neill Solicitors)


For Tuesday 24th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
284/16 DPP -v- James Lammon (KRW Law Solicitors)

For Thursday 26th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
199/19 DPP -v- Inga Ozolina (John Shanley Solicitors)

Sentence Appeals
72/19 DPP -v- D McD (Keenan & Company Solicitors)
66/19 DPP -v- Kenneth Broe (John O'Leary & Co Solicitors)
148/19 DPP -v- Mark Harte (Jenny McGeever Solicitors)

For Friday 27th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
at 10 o'clock
Case-mgt List

At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeals
93/17 DPP -v- Michael McCarville (Michael Hennessy Solicitors)
138/19 DPP -v- Andrew Beatty

Civil Appeal
2019 208 Ross -v- DPP

For Monday 30th March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction and Sentence Appeal
48/19 DPP -v- Conor Metcalfe (Kieran Conway Solicitors)

Conviction and Sentence Appeal / Undue Leniency Application
118/19 & 131CJA/19 DPP -v- Damien Metcalfe (Kieran Conway Solicitors)

For Tuesday 31st March 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
40/12 DPP -v- Noel O'Connor (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

Conviction and Sentence
96/16 DPP -v- Stephen Kane (Burns Nowlan & Co. Solicitors)

For Thursday 2nd April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeals
132/17 DPP -v- Dylan Hayes (Kiely McCarthy Solicitors)
178/17 DPP -v- Gerard Hogan (Darach McCarthy & Company Solicitors)

For Friday 3rd April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
at 10 o'clock
Case-mgt List

At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
294/18 DPP -v- Regina Keogh (Emer O'Sullivan & Co. Solicitors)


EASTER TERM 2020


For Monday 20th April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
101/19 DPP -v- Mihai Tache (Tracy Horan & Co. Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
18/19 DPP -v- Warren Nolan (Lorraine J Stephens Solicitor)

For Tuesday 21st April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeals
122/19 DPP -v- Derek Flynn (Phelim O'Neill Solicitors)

273/18 DPP -v- Patrick Byrnes (Phelim O'Neill Solicitors)

For Thursday 23rd April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
26/19 DPP -v- Michael Joyce (Phelim O'Neill Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
133/17 DPP-v- C C (John Casey & Co. Solicitors)

Civil Appeal
2019 352 Galvin -v- DPP

For Friday 24th April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case-mgt list

For Monday 27th April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
Undue Leniency (for further hearing)
54CJA/17 DPP-v-James Preston (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)

For Tuesday 28th April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal & Enl of time
188/2018 DPP -v- Ian O'Sullivan (Sheehan & Partners Solicitors)

For Thursday 30th April 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction Appeal
111/19 DPP -v- Joseph McGrane (Michael Staines & Co. Solicitors)
168/17 DPP -v- Nicholas Cahill (O'Flaherty & Brown Solicitors)

For Friday 1st May 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case-mgt list

At 10.30 o'clock
Conviction and sentence
51/16 DPP-v- Daniel Wyse (John Shanley Solicitors)

For Friday 8th May 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case-mgt list

For Monday 18th May 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
List to Fix Dates

For Friday 22nd May 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
Case-mgt list


TRINITY TERM 2020

For Monday 13th July 2020
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o'clock
Sentence Appeal
41/19 DPP -v- Jamie Crowley (Edmund J. Burke & Co. Solicitors)